Cities in the developed world face challenges retrofitting tech into the built environment, while those in the developing world have the opportunity to install it early on. But all of them could benefit by sharing best-practices, says Peter Madden, chief executive of the Future Cities Catapult.
Re: Sharing best practices In fairness, open source software isn't much without proprietary adaptations. So that makes it ideal for enterprise systems, and a great way for big vendors to maintain their lead in software development services.
Re: Sharing best practices Indeed, mejiac, there is a compelling argument for open source; and I think that in recent years, we've seen the benefits of this approach -- and hence its increased credibility with enterprises and vendors.
At the same time, open source doesn't preclude vendors from the kind of development work and proprietary adaptations they specialize in.
Agreed, there are IT solutions that should be shared, reason why I think that open source those provide ways for cities to implemente prototype solutions, that can be then tailored for a definitive implementation.
Re: Sharing best practices I think it depends, Rich. While some technology is important to keep for profit, there are a lot of IT solutions that can and should be shared widely or even standardized. An example is network management. For years, vendors kept the management of their wares so proprietary that it made it extremely difficult for users to manage their multivendor networks. It wasn't that the vendors made a lot of money on management; it's that they just didn't believe in working to help a multivendor environment.
Re: Sharing best practices Yes, you're right Mary. But James's comment was about inventions and discoveries being "held ransom for profit". To me, that suggests an argument that they should be given away to all and sundry, and that it's bad for the technology provider to make a profit from that knowledge. But perhaps I've missed the point and, if I have, I hope James will correct me.
Re: Sharing best practices I think what the video describes, though, is the need for cities to share what they find useful in tech. This is different from vendors giving away the store. If a city has succeeded, for instance, in implementing a parking automation plan, then why shouldn't that plan be shared with a neighboring municipality, including the vendors and contractors used?
Reinventing the wheel is so counterproductive when it comes to city projects.
Re: Sharing best practices That'd be ideal, James. But, given the economic system we're working in, do you think this sort of widespread sharing of ideas and technology is realistic? If companies spend a lot of time and money developing new inventions, do we really want them to give them away for nothing? If they do that then surely they wouldn't have the money to invest in creating the next invention.
Re: Sharing best practices Nyet, we need more sharing between and outside of our boundaries to benifit all of mankind. Inventions and discoveries that become proprietary and held ransom for profit hold back urban development. As our world becomes smaller we need to be able to trust and develop with each other to reach our full potential and become really smart cities and civilizations.
Sharing best practices Great points here. Sharing best practices is so important anywhere, but particularly in cities that are seeking to advance and build on past good experience. Do we need any stronger endorsement these days of cooperation in all urban endeavors?
Smart City Money Makers companies and solutions that are most prominent, and destined to be most profitable, in the smart city revolution.
How to Make Your City Smarter Cities all over the world need to become smarter and more sustainable. But where to start? Download this guide to learn the first, proven steps toward making your city smarter.
Site Moderators Future Cities is looking for engaged readers to moderate the message boards on this site. Engage in high-IQ conversations; earn kudos and perks. Interested? E-mail: firstname.lastname@example.org
Designed to provide the people with access to green building products all year round